Abby Taylor believes in her soul that she was meant to be a mother. But starting late in life, she and her husband were forced to try fertility treatments that left them broke and without options. Looking for a fresh start now that they have decided to officially 'stop trying', Abby attends a transformational 'Breakthroughs and Miracles' seminar led by best-selling author and self-help guru, Sarah Linda McCormick. But what Abby isn't telling anyone, including her husband, is that she is really there to meet with an anonymous sperm donor that she found online. She's going to take one more chance at conceiving a child, even if it means she could lose so much more in the process. If I Could Tell You not only delves into the struggle experienced by many who deal with infertility, but also showcases the new lengths some are going to through the online underworld of fertility treatments – guys who donate their sperm to women for free, or even have sex with them to get them pregnant.